Alcoholics can moderate their drinking

Don’t worry, I’m going somewhere with this. Don’t write me outraged comments just yet.

Caroline Knapp, talking about hitting bottom, discusses the ‘leap’ that many active alcoholics take, a period of time that marks the distinction between mid- and late- stage alcoholism. The leap is the switch that gets flicked where someone who has been struggling to stay functional, and to keep dancing on the invisible line between a secret problem and an obvious one, sometimes takes. It can happen in response to a trauma (in Knapp’s case, it was losing both parents to different cancers within a year) or just because the drinker gets sick of hiding the problem, and on some level wants to force the issue. From there, the drinker is going to do one of two things: hit bottom and get help, or hit bottom and die.

So far, none of this is unusual. I think that even those of us who aren’t there yet, who haven’t moved into that phase, are familiar with the Fuck-it’s; those nights where, for whatever reason, we decide that we don’t care tonight. We will just drink the way we want to, no holds-barred, to get obliterated. The last time I did this, a week before I quit, LH and I were trialling a no-drinking-during-the-.week phase, and I was juggling a stressful time at work as well as my disabled mother’s latest health and finances crisis, and I came home on a Monday night, declared that I didn’t care tonight, I needed wine, and I drank steadily and heavily all evening, ignoring LH and his eyes on me.

In fact, it’s pretty normal for people with a drinking problem, who live with partners or family, to say that they looked forward to nights on their own because they could drink more without worrying about how it looked. Or to drink before an evening out, so as to be able to drink slowly once there. Or to limit oneself to two glasses at a party, knowing that there is a bottle waiting at home once there are no eyes to see.

We associate all of these behaviours with secret drinking, a sure sign of a problem itself. Even if we aren’t hiding wine casks in the rafters of our house, like an old colleague of mine did, it’s all behaviour designed to minimise the amount that other people see us drink, to keep our secret: we know that we don’t drink like other people.

It is also a form of moderation. Us drinkers, we practice moderation all the time. We watch the clock until the hands finally scrape past five pm. We count our drinks at dinner, and count other peoples drinks, to try and keep pace. We offer to drive when we know we can’t trust ourselves to stay acceptable otherwise.

oh, I never really tried moderation properly, maybe if I put more effort into it or even the closer-to-reality I know I can’t moderate; I tried and failed both ignore something huge. And that something is that nobody, nobody, succeeds in moderating their intake more successfully than an alcoholic. Not enough effort? Some days, it takes all of our effort. And we succeed, right up until we don’t. And that’s when Knapp’s leap occurs, when we finally stop moderating and swan dive down to the rocky, dark, terrifying bottom.

Of course alcoholics can moderate. It’s all we ever do. But moderating; which let’s face it, means for an addict that we are exerting willpower every minute of every day to resist the urge to obliterate, sucks.

So you can leap. Or you can stop.


9 thoughts on “Alcoholics can moderate their drinking

  1. This really, really resonates with me at 111 days and fairly settled in sober land but I just keep peeping through the cracks back to booze land and seeing the light, not the whole story. If I look at the whole story I don’t want to go back there, I don’t even know why I think about it. I love reading your updates -well done on the move and your toasting with Aspro really bought a smile to my day x

  2. Holy Shit….. I never read Knapp’s book but everything you wrote about drinking before you go out or drinking excess at home after the event was me. Downing a glass when BF pulled in the driveway and refilling before he walked in was me…. All of it! How horrible that was. Well I reached our fir help finally, telling my AA friend I don’t want to hit a big rock bottom, this bottom is far enough!!!

    Thanks for the great post! Hope your internet is up soon! Congrats on the new place!

  3. Great post. You’ve been spying on me….sums me up so well. Isn’t it amazing how quickly our thoughts go to the romance of drinking. That lover begging us to come back. Thanks for writing this.

  4. Loved this, and your last post about how it would be if you drank again. (Something I think about too often.) Thought this was a really interesting take. Always assumed that I wasn’t good enough at moderation, but you’re absolutely right. Now that I’ve stopped, I can see this in the way that some other people I know drink too – that steely grip of control, because if you keep that steely grip you can keep on drinking, right? And as you say, we succeed, right up until we don’t. And ooh, the effort! It is such a relief not to have to do that any more. That, along with the sleep, the skin, the lack of a hangover thing, is one of the things I like best about sobriety. xxx

  5. Ping ping ping! The sound of lightbulbs going off above my head as I can hold my hands up to every one of those ways I moderated my drinking around others xx

  6. Pingback: Black and White Thinking and Booze | A hangover free life

  7. Pingback: Awesome essay about alcoholics moderating - SoberRecovery : Alcoholism Drug Addiction Help and Information

  8. Great post, I just found your blog, I am really enjoying your writing and how honestly you share your feelings. When I started with the behaviors that you describe in the post, I really knew it was time. It takes so much effort to moderate, it really is just easier not to drink. I remember clearly one night being out with friends and I was in amazement at how one of my friends ordered a glass of wine before dinner and by the time dessert arrived had just drank half. It is images like that in my mind that help me to stick to this new way of life. Sure it would be great to have 1 glass of wine with dinner every night, but I know now I wouldn’t last for a week. So here I am happily at 8 months.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s